Cover Image for An UNMUTED Book Club: My Promised Land
Cover Image for An UNMUTED Book Club: My Promised Land
Avatar for UNMUTED
Presented by
UNMUTED
Talk politics. Keep your friends.
Hosted By
1 Going

An UNMUTED Book Club: My Promised Land

Registration
Approval Required
Your registration is subject to host approval.
Welcome! To join the event, please register below.
About Event

​READING NOT REQUIRED - just be curious!

​Next up: Ari Shavit's My Promised Land: The Triumph and Tragedy of Israel, the 2013 book that argues Israel's founding was both an extraordinary achievement of Jewish national self-determination and a tragedy for the Palestinians who paid the price.

​Shavit, an Israeli journalist and longtime columnist for Haaretz, tells the story of Israel through pivotal moments in its history, beginning with the early Zionist pioneers and moving through the Holocaust, the founding of Israel in 1948, the occupation of the West Bank, and the failures of the peace process. Drawing on historical documents, interviews, and his own family's experiences, he makes a provocative argument: that Zionism was both a necessary response to centuries of Jewish persecution and a movement that inflicted profound suffering on another people. His account of the 1948 expulsion of Palestinians from Lydda is especially striking, forcing readers to confront whether Israel's creation could have happened without Palestinian dispossession.

​It's a deeply personal examination of a country Shavit clearly loves but refuses to romanticize, raising uncomfortable questions about nationalism, historical responsibility, and whether a nation's founding can be both morally justified and morally compromised.

​Show up even if you only got through a chunk. We'll talk about where Shavit's account is most convincing, where it leaves out important context, whether he successfully reconciles Zionism with the Palestinian Nakba, and whether acknowledging the injustices of Israel's founding strengthens or undermines the case for its legitimacy today. We'll also consider how his interpretation compares with Rashid Khalidi's The Hundred Years' War on Palestine, and what these competing narratives mean for the possibility of peace.

​UNMUTED is a discussion forum for the politically curious. Accessible. Engaging. Social. Open-minded is the name of the game. Join your people.

Location
Café-Flor / Bar 21
218 8th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA
Avatar for UNMUTED
Presented by
UNMUTED
Talk politics. Keep your friends.
Hosted By
1 Going